Notices
Stock JK Tech Bulletin board forum regarding issues with OE (original equipment) components of the Jeep JK Wrangler (Rubicon, Sahara, Unlimited and X) such as factory suspension parts, engine, transmission, body parts, interior fixtures and the on-board computer.

possible problems with some 3.6 pentastar engines

Thread Tools
 
Old 08-17-2012 | 07:58 PM
  #821  
MGM2's Avatar
JK Newbie
 
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
From: PASADENA CA.
Default

Originally Posted by Sunkist Rubi
This is becoming too much for me. You wonder why people say you can't believe everything you read on the internet. This is a perfect example of the lunacy that permeates this entire thread.

Nothing is getting blocked inside the head/exhaust manifold and stopping the flow of exhaust to the atmosphere. There is no increase in density occurring because there is no constriction of the gas flow. The exhaust will escape because the cylinder pressures greatly exceeds the atmospheric pressure. If what you are saying is happening, the exhaust gases are being constricted, the engine would not function properly and completely stall. Yes, there could be a build-up of excess heat because all the cylinders exhaust through this singular passage.

As I've stated many times before in this thread, a lifter is being starved of oil right from the very beginning of the engine's life. Every lifter has it's own internal spring that does the job of supporting a zero valve lash gap but for only so long. Without a constant support of oil pressure this internal valve spring will only last for so long. I physically observed the one lifter that failed in my Jeep. Compared to the other lifters there was no resistance remaining, no force to keep the valve lash gap to zero. THIS IS WHAT CAUSES THE INFAMOUS TIC.

This is the last time I will make this statement. Everybody that doesn't understand the hydraulic valve actuation process should Google it and do some reading. A lot of very false accusations that are rampant throughout this thread would end. Please do us all a favor and do some research and LEARN. The internet is a very powerful tool LEARN HOW TO USE IT. Goodbye.

Right !!!!! Thats what I said!!!!

Also... the lifter bore could be machined to large or the oiling hole in the casting is partially blocked thats why the need to replace the head.

if the lifter collapses the valve does not open causing a misfire.

There also could be a problem with the valve guide not getting oil, causing it to wear out or get loose and the valve not closing causing a misfire.

Last edited by MGM2; 08-17-2012 at 08:12 PM.
Old 08-17-2012 | 08:04 PM
  #822  
RoysRig's Avatar
JK Super Freak
 
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 3
From: Mile High Colorado
Default

Originally Posted by Sunkist Rubi
I only speak of what is actually happening from my experience of this problem and what I had to go through.

I've completely rebuilt more then one engine in my life; I have a very good understanding on how the entire internal combustion engine works. I didn't say you had to take my word for it; you can believe what you want. Like I said Google and learn about hydraulic lifter systems; I don't make up the rules it is what it is.

From what I understand and what I've stated more then once in this thread; there is an oil gallery line that may be clogged due to poor head castings. This stops the flow to a specific lifter where the only way it initially works is through it's own internal spring. This internal spring was not meant to support the valve lash adjustment for the entire life of the engine. in other words; this is not the way it was designed. Because a lifter is being starved of the required oil to pressurize it and maintain the zero valve lash requirement; it fails.

As I previously stated I physically viewed my failed lifter at my dealer when my head was replaced. The Service Manager showed me the failed lifter. Comparing it to the others it was weaker then a wet noodle. There was absolutely no spring resistance left. The other lifters could not be depressed no matter how hard I tried.
Well just as much as you hate the rumor mill on the internet(but that is what makes the internet fun) I hate the bs that comes out of service departments. Case and point, I have a little kia and the dealer sends me the coupons for service. And I get to laughing so hard at them. One of the coupons were for a Valve adjustment to my Kia Forte. I called the service writer and asked, "Valve Adjustment? What in the hell are you performing in this Valve Adjustment?" And his response was they set the lobe lash. I said, but I have hydraulic lifters. Just how are they going to do that? He said, hold on let me talk to one of the techs, he puts me on hold for 10 minutes and comes back, he said, Sir you are correct and that it was more of a inspection. And I said so your going to pull the head to inspect the valves? He said, well no....I'm not really sure what they do. Needless to say, they've never seen the car sense.

Here it is.. couldn't find a way to post the html from the email so I'll just do a copy and paste of the text from it.

Tune-up Special
$195.95

Replace Spark Plugs
Replace Air Filter
And
Adjust Valves <----- what the hell is this?


and then this one
Pick Your Oil Change
Good
Regular Oil Change
$19.95

Better
Synthetic Oil Change
$49.95

Best
Synthetic Oil
$68.95


Can someone tell me the difference between the Better and Best?


And then there is this one....
10% Off
Tire Rotation
Tire Alignment <------ What is a tire Alignment?
Balance Tires
Check Pressure
Old 08-17-2012 | 08:11 PM
  #823  
BrandRezake's Avatar
JK Enthusiast
 
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 107
Likes: 1
From: Orlando, FL
Default

Originally Posted by RoysRig

Well just as much as you hate the rumor mill on the internet(but that is what makes the internet fun) I hate the bs that comes out of service departments. Case and point, I have a little kia and the dealer sends me the coupons for service. And I get to laughing so hard at them. One of the coupons were for a Valve adjustment to my Kia Forte. I called the service writer and asked, "Valve Adjustment? What in the hell are you performing in this Valve Adjustment?" And his response was they set the lobe lash. I said, but I have hydraulic lifters. Just how are they going to do that? He said, hold on let me talk to one of the techs, he puts me on hold for 10 minutes and comes back, he said, Sir you are correct and that it was more of a inspection. And I said so your going to pull the head to inspect the valves? He said, well no....I'm not really sure what they do. Needless to say, they've never seen the car sense.

Here it is.. couldn't find a way to post the html from the email so I'll just do a copy and paste of the text from it.

Tune-up Special
$195.95

Replace Spark Plugs
Replace Air Filter
And
Adjust Valves <----- what the hell is this?

and then this one
Pick Your Oil Change
Good
Regular Oil Change
$19.95

Better
Synthetic Oil Change
$49.95

Best
Synthetic Oil
$68.95

Can someone tell me the difference between the Better and Best?

And then there is this one....
10% Off
Tire Rotation
Tire Alignment <------ What is a tire Alignment?
Balance Tires
Check Pressure
Lmfao. That was a good read.
Old 08-17-2012 | 08:15 PM
  #824  
33 williys 77's Avatar
JK Junkie
 
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 2,192
Likes: 2
From: SoCal
Default

Originally Posted by RoysRig
Well just looking at this picture I would guess Head first. water pump intake is high and next to the heads.
If Chrysler is cooling the head first then it is a design flaw with the old heads and if these heads have ( what we use to call steam ports ) then maybe the NEW heads have larger steam ports for more coolant flow.

Just a guess or conjecture on my part

33

Old 08-17-2012 | 08:22 PM
  #825  
RoysRig's Avatar
JK Super Freak
 
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 3
From: Mile High Colorado
Default

Originally Posted by Sunkist Rubi
I don't know where these different size tubes, diameters, primaries came from. I never said anything about the exact size of the exhaust manifold geometries referring to this single passage volume. I've also never read anything official direct from Chrysler or anybody else officially related referring to these various exhaust diameters. This reads like somebody came up with this info on their own and placed it into this thread.

The head has to be designed to flow the amount of exhaust it exudes from the cylinders; if it didn't the engine couldn't run. As we all know the engine runs just fine; at least mine does and a few of my friends who have the same engine installed in various Chrysler models.
Well I might have digressed a little there, my point was that I don't know that the pentastar is using the most efficient methods for the exhaust. I think they found a way to get the cats up close so that they can perform well and lower emissions. It also has a great way of reducing the size of the exhaust manifolds, and we all know there isn't much room left in the engine compartment in the 2012. But the short primarys are always the performance killer. That's why the performance car guys love the long tubes. But the smog nazi's don't like the long tubes because the gases have cooled by the time it reaches the relocated cat and looses its efficiency. But pentastar doesn't even utilize a short primary, they've got mega short primaries. Having seen a performance difference between a short, mid, and long, I can only start to imagine just how much power could be found with a typical head instead of this merged exhaust porting.
Old 08-17-2012 | 08:24 PM
  #826  
RoysRig's Avatar
JK Super Freak
 
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 3
From: Mile High Colorado
Default

Originally Posted by 33 williys 77
If Chrysler is cooling the head first then it is a design flaw with the old heads and if these heads have ( what we use to call steam ports ) then maybe the NEW heads have larger steam ports for more coolant flow.

Just a guess or conjecture on my part

33

Yea I kinda figured the metal was hot coming out, and the heater core feeder should be the hot coming out, and the composite would be the cooler liquid going in.
Old 08-17-2012 | 08:32 PM
  #827  
Sunkist Rubi's Avatar
JK Enthusiast
 
Joined: Dec 2011
Posts: 115
Likes: 0
From: Connecticut
Default

[QUOTE=RoysRig;3167781]Well just as much as you hate the rumor mill on the internet(but that is what makes the internet fun) I hate the bs that comes out of service departments. Case and point, I have a little kia and the dealer sends me the coupons for service. And I get to laughing so hard at them. One of the coupons were for a Valve adjustment to my Kia Forte. I called the service writer and asked, "Valve Adjustment? What in the hell are you performing in this Valve Adjustment?" And his response was they set the lobe lash. I said, but I have hydraulic lifters. Just how are they going to do that? He said, hold on let me talk to one of the techs, he puts me on hold for 10 minutes and comes back, he said, Sir you are correct and that it was more of a inspection. And I said so your going to pull the head to inspect the valves? He said, well no....I'm not really sure what they do. Needless to say, they've never seen the car sense.

That is what ruins the accuracy of the internet. I understand there are people who think they know what they are talking about but they really don't.

I didn't understand exactly know how the valve system worked in the Pentastar when I learned of this problem. I knew it was a hydraulic system but the way Chrysler called out the various component names and descriptions made it sound super exotic. After I dug a little deeper through internet research and through my past experience I realized it was nothing more then a normal hydraulic actuated system, and quite simple as well. Thorough research also helps you look much more intelligent when you go back to your dealer and you actually know what you're talking about.

In other words I didn't jump on to this thread and pretend I knew what I was talking about. Even though you people don't have a clue to who I am, I don't like adding inaccurate info to further confuse the situation.

This entire forum is to help people who are looking for answers to their problems. Wouldn't it be nice if we could actually help them, correctly based on our personal knowledge, and hard earned experience?
Old 08-17-2012 | 08:46 PM
  #828  
RoysRig's Avatar
JK Super Freak
 
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 3
From: Mile High Colorado
Default

Originally Posted by Sunkist Rubi
Well just as much as you hate the rumor mill on the internet(but that is what makes the internet fun) I hate the bs that comes out of service departments. Case and point, I have a little kia and the dealer sends me the coupons for service. And I get to laughing so hard at them. One of the coupons were for a Valve adjustment to my Kia Forte. I called the service writer and asked, "Valve Adjustment? What in the hell are you performing in this Valve Adjustment?" And his response was they set the lobe lash. I said, but I have hydraulic lifters. Just how are they going to do that? He said, hold on let me talk to one of the techs, he puts me on hold for 10 minutes and comes back, he said, Sir you are correct and that it was more of a inspection. And I said so your going to pull the head to inspect the valves? He said, well no....I'm not really sure what they do. Needless to say, they've never seen the car sense.

That is what ruins the accuracy of the internet. I understand there are people who think they know what they are talking about but they really don't.

I didn't understand exactly know how the valve system worked in the Pentastar when I learned of this problem. I knew it was a hydraulic system but the way Chrysler called out the various component names and descriptions made it sound super exotic. After I dug a little deeper through internet research and through my past experience I realized it was nothing more then a normal hydraulic actuated system, and quite simple as well. Thorough research also helps you look much more intelligent when you go back to your dealer and you actually know what you're talking about.

In other words I didn't jump on to this thread and pretend I knew what I was talking about. Even though you people don't have a clue to who I am, I don't like adding inaccurate info to further confuse the situation.

This entire forum is to help people who are looking for answers to their problems. Wouldn't it be nice if we could actually help them, correctly based on our personal knowledge, and hard earned experience?

Well the real problem is coming from Chrysler's lack of forth coming information. All the little tidbits are very cryptic. So sometimes it's good to throw ideas out there, kind of a brain storm session, and develop our own hypothesis. And in my world that's a weekly event. Problems come up, get a bunch of people throwing out possibilities, so long as people keep an open mind, the problems eventually become quite clear. I think it's great that we are getting people like you that can give us first hand experience and valid data, but we have to always consider the fact that it may not be just one problem with the pentastar.
Old 08-17-2012 | 09:07 PM
  #829  
Sunkist Rubi's Avatar
JK Enthusiast
 
Joined: Dec 2011
Posts: 115
Likes: 0
From: Connecticut
Default

Originally Posted by RoysRig
Well the real problem is coming from Chrysler's lack of forth coming information. All the little tidbits are very cryptic. So sometimes it's good to throw ideas out there, kind of a brain storm session, and develop our own hypothesis. And in my world that's a weekly event. Problems come up, get a bunch of people throwing out possibilities, so long as people keep an open mind, the problems eventually become quite clear. I think it's great that we are getting people like you that can give us first hand experience and valid data, but we have to always consider the fact that it may not be just one problem with the pentastar.
Yes I understand and practice brainstorming quite a bit at my job as well.

It's frustrating to understand the real problem in all of this. Although the lifters are being starved of oil we don't really know the actual reason why this is happening. I mentioned clogged oil galleries, but Chrysler is being very quiet about this and I would think they know exactly where and why the problem is occurring.

What's bothering me, and I just learned of this from this thread tonight; is the single exhaust passage out of the engine on each bank of cylinders. Chrysler says this will not cause any problems but I had planned on keeping my JKR for more then 100k miles. This may or may not be a very durable design. In my knowledge this is a brand new head design which means it probably was never done this way before.

I would like to know if anybody knows of any 3.6L Pentastar exceeding 100K miles yet. Our warranty may last that many miles but what modern engine do you know of that doesn't attain at least 150k without any problems? How about 200k; there are many engines that get to this level on a regular basis. Do you think the Pentastar will make it that far?
Old 08-17-2012 | 09:20 PM
  #830  
RoysRig's Avatar
JK Super Freak
 
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1,476
Likes: 3
From: Mile High Colorado
Default

Originally Posted by Sunkist Rubi
Yes I understand and practice brainstorming quite a bit at my job as well.

single exhaust passage out of the engine on each bank of cylinders.

Well, this is my first Jeep, and one of the first things that kinda put me back on my heels was how much heat is created under the hood. Having a lot of V8's in my day and racing at Bandimere, I've never encountered so much heat being produced, especially from a mere v6. And I mention this being my first jeep because maybe someone else can tell me if the heat issue is in all models and years, or is it worse in the >2012? And I can't help but wonder if the extra distance that the exhaust has to travel to escape the area of the block/heads isn't soaked up in that travel. This new head really was an outside of the box design.


Quick Reply: possible problems with some 3.6 pentastar engines



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:31 AM.