2012 JK Engine pinging / knocking
#1
JK Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2012 JK Engine pinging / knocking
hi folks,
Sorry if you guys think this is an obvious issue, but I'm looking for help with a noise that I'm guessing is spark knock or engine ping on my 2012 JKU (3.6 pentastar, w/ manual). It started at about 3000 miles, and as gotten worse over time (I now have 14000). It seems to exist between about 1700 and 2100 RPM or so, and I find it in 3,4,5,6 gears. It improves somewhat when I use high-octane fuel (which is why I think it is spark knock), but by no means goes away, and it is irritating to have to use the expense gas. It only happens when the vehicle is warm (so ironically my favorite time driving the jeep is when it hasn't warmed up). And it seems a worse in hot weather. It was really bad when driving in the summer with my small (<1000 lb) trailer full of camping gear, especially on modest grades, though this was before I started using premium. When its bad its really bad, like makes you grimace and is not fun for driver or passenger -- makes me want to get rid of the jeep (which I otherwise love and focus much of my attention on).
The dealership says I just need to use premium, and that's as far as I've got with them. Will try going back, but I don't want to be told that it is par of a JK.
Anyone else had this problem?
I'm perplexed as to how a brand new engine in this day and age can have this problem. The last time I had this was on an 84 Land Cruiser FJ60 (with a carburetor!).
I've heard it said that this is due to carbon deposits... can someone educate me as to how this works? I thought it was somehow due to the fact that the spark fires before the optimal time in the piston stroke, i.e. a timing problem. Seems like it could be fixed electronically... (Thanks for the education). I've also heard that it can be improved with the combustion chamber cleaner, but this also doesn't make sense to me.
Thanks in advance!
Sorry if you guys think this is an obvious issue, but I'm looking for help with a noise that I'm guessing is spark knock or engine ping on my 2012 JKU (3.6 pentastar, w/ manual). It started at about 3000 miles, and as gotten worse over time (I now have 14000). It seems to exist between about 1700 and 2100 RPM or so, and I find it in 3,4,5,6 gears. It improves somewhat when I use high-octane fuel (which is why I think it is spark knock), but by no means goes away, and it is irritating to have to use the expense gas. It only happens when the vehicle is warm (so ironically my favorite time driving the jeep is when it hasn't warmed up). And it seems a worse in hot weather. It was really bad when driving in the summer with my small (<1000 lb) trailer full of camping gear, especially on modest grades, though this was before I started using premium. When its bad its really bad, like makes you grimace and is not fun for driver or passenger -- makes me want to get rid of the jeep (which I otherwise love and focus much of my attention on).
The dealership says I just need to use premium, and that's as far as I've got with them. Will try going back, but I don't want to be told that it is par of a JK.
Anyone else had this problem?
I'm perplexed as to how a brand new engine in this day and age can have this problem. The last time I had this was on an 84 Land Cruiser FJ60 (with a carburetor!).
I've heard it said that this is due to carbon deposits... can someone educate me as to how this works? I thought it was somehow due to the fact that the spark fires before the optimal time in the piston stroke, i.e. a timing problem. Seems like it could be fixed electronically... (Thanks for the education). I've also heard that it can be improved with the combustion chamber cleaner, but this also doesn't make sense to me.
Thanks in advance!
#2
Super Moderator
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Posts: 11,043
Likes: 0
Received 83 Likes
on
75 Posts
It sounds like you are dealing with carbon buildup. It can be caused by anything from cheap fuel to driving habits, and many winter blend fuel mixtures make it worse. I have found a good way to help this, as I have dealt with it myself. 1) get a bottle of seafoam at an auto parts store, and put in in a full gas tank. 2) go to the dealership and grab a bottle of Chrysler combustion chamber cleaner. Follow the directions. It is sprayed directly into the throttle body, then you shut off the engine for several hours if possible. When finished, take it for a good hard drive to blow everything out. It wouldn't be a bad time to change the oil either. Try this and tell us how it does. If buildup is bad, it may require two treatments.
#3
JK Enthusiast
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Lima, ny
Posts: 436
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hi folks,
Sorry if you guys think this is an obvious issue, but I'm looking for help with a noise that I'm guessing is spark knock or engine ping on my 2012 JKU (3.6 pentastar, w/ manual). It started at about 3000 miles, and as gotten worse over time (I now have 14000). It seems to exist between about 1700 and 2100 RPM or so, and I find it in 3,4,5,6 gears. It improves somewhat when I use high-octane fuel (which is why I think it is spark knock), but by no means goes away, and it is irritating to have to use the expense gas. It only happens when the vehicle is warm (so ironically my favorite time driving the jeep is when it hasn't warmed up). And it seems a worse in hot weather. It was really bad when driving in the summer with my small (<1000 lb) trailer full of camping gear, especially on modest grades, though this was before I started using premium. When its bad its really bad, like makes you grimace and is not fun for driver or passenger -- makes me want to get rid of the jeep (which I otherwise love and focus much of my attention on).
The dealership says I just need to use premium, and that's as far as I've got with them. Will try going back, but I don't want to be told that it is par of a JK.
Anyone else had this problem?
I'm perplexed as to how a brand new engine in this day and age can have this problem. The last time I had this was on an 84 Land Cruiser FJ60 (with a carburetor!).
I've heard it said that this is due to carbon deposits... can someone educate me as to how this works? I thought it was somehow due to the fact that the spark fires before the optimal time in the piston stroke, i.e. a timing problem. Seems like it could be fixed electronically... (Thanks for the education). I've also heard that it can be improved with the combustion chamber cleaner, but this also doesn't make sense to me.
Thanks in advance!
Sorry if you guys think this is an obvious issue, but I'm looking for help with a noise that I'm guessing is spark knock or engine ping on my 2012 JKU (3.6 pentastar, w/ manual). It started at about 3000 miles, and as gotten worse over time (I now have 14000). It seems to exist between about 1700 and 2100 RPM or so, and I find it in 3,4,5,6 gears. It improves somewhat when I use high-octane fuel (which is why I think it is spark knock), but by no means goes away, and it is irritating to have to use the expense gas. It only happens when the vehicle is warm (so ironically my favorite time driving the jeep is when it hasn't warmed up). And it seems a worse in hot weather. It was really bad when driving in the summer with my small (<1000 lb) trailer full of camping gear, especially on modest grades, though this was before I started using premium. When its bad its really bad, like makes you grimace and is not fun for driver or passenger -- makes me want to get rid of the jeep (which I otherwise love and focus much of my attention on).
The dealership says I just need to use premium, and that's as far as I've got with them. Will try going back, but I don't want to be told that it is par of a JK.
Anyone else had this problem?
I'm perplexed as to how a brand new engine in this day and age can have this problem. The last time I had this was on an 84 Land Cruiser FJ60 (with a carburetor!).
I've heard it said that this is due to carbon deposits... can someone educate me as to how this works? I thought it was somehow due to the fact that the spark fires before the optimal time in the piston stroke, i.e. a timing problem. Seems like it could be fixed electronically... (Thanks for the education). I've also heard that it can be improved with the combustion chamber cleaner, but this also doesn't make sense to me.
Thanks in advance!
#4
JK Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks guys. The notion of the carbon deposits glowing hot helps.
So is this indicative of piston rings not sealing well, or some other fundamental engine problem? Would / could synthetic oil or a different weight of oil help?
I did look a bit at the head issue, but was under the impression that that was a ticking that you would hear at idle, and I haven't really noticed this. My noise is more like a rattle coming from somewhere when in the aforementioned RPM range and under load (even moderate load). Truth is, I originally thought it might be coming from the transmission, but I took it to the dealer and they drove around with me in it and said it is spark knock, and that I needed to use the premium fuel. And then it did seem to improve, even go away temporarily when I started with the premium, so that seems to be the right track. But it has by no means vanished altogether.
I'm really hoping I can find a way to solve this so I can start 'investing' in my future happiness with mods, tires, etc.
So is this indicative of piston rings not sealing well, or some other fundamental engine problem? Would / could synthetic oil or a different weight of oil help?
I did look a bit at the head issue, but was under the impression that that was a ticking that you would hear at idle, and I haven't really noticed this. My noise is more like a rattle coming from somewhere when in the aforementioned RPM range and under load (even moderate load). Truth is, I originally thought it might be coming from the transmission, but I took it to the dealer and they drove around with me in it and said it is spark knock, and that I needed to use the premium fuel. And then it did seem to improve, even go away temporarily when I started with the premium, so that seems to be the right track. But it has by no means vanished altogether.
I'm really hoping I can find a way to solve this so I can start 'investing' in my future happiness with mods, tires, etc.
#5
JK Enthusiast
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Lima, ny
Posts: 436
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks guys. The notion of the carbon deposits glowing hot helps.
So is this indicative of piston rings not sealing well, or some other fundamental engine problem? Would / could synthetic oil or a different weight of oil help?
I did look a bit at the head issue, but was under the impression that that was a ticking that you would hear at idle, and I haven't really noticed this. My noise is more like a rattle coming from somewhere when in the aforementioned RPM range and under load (even moderate load). Truth is, I originally thought it might be coming from the transmission, but I took it to the dealer and they drove around with me in it and said it is spark knock, and that I needed to use the premium fuel. And then it did seem to improve, even go away temporarily when I started with the premium, so that seems to be the right track. But it has by no means vanished altogether.
I'm really hoping I can find a way to solve this so I can start 'investing' in my future happiness with mods, tires, etc.
So is this indicative of piston rings not sealing well, or some other fundamental engine problem? Would / could synthetic oil or a different weight of oil help?
I did look a bit at the head issue, but was under the impression that that was a ticking that you would hear at idle, and I haven't really noticed this. My noise is more like a rattle coming from somewhere when in the aforementioned RPM range and under load (even moderate load). Truth is, I originally thought it might be coming from the transmission, but I took it to the dealer and they drove around with me in it and said it is spark knock, and that I needed to use the premium fuel. And then it did seem to improve, even go away temporarily when I started with the premium, so that seems to be the right track. But it has by no means vanished altogether.
I'm really hoping I can find a way to solve this so I can start 'investing' in my future happiness with mods, tires, etc.
#6
This is the Cylinder Head issue the early 2012's have been having. It is common with all of the early 3.6 penastars. They have to replace the drivers side cylinder head. It usually is mis firing on cylinder 4. Do some searching on the forum. It is such a problem that the delerships are only allocated one cylinder head per month. It took my dealership 3 months to get one in for mine. Mine was actually mis firing on both the left and right banks, and yes the warmer the engine gets the louder it gets. Your dealership should know what the issue is. If they say they don't they are playing dumb, or theyr mechanics just hate doing the cylinder head job. The dealerships get 70 hrs. of labor from chrysler for the job. It took them about three days to complete mine and it runs great. Power has returned and not having any issues.
Check out these threads,
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...t=3.6+penastar
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...astar+problems
Check out these threads,
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...t=3.6+penastar
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...astar+problems
Last edited by HornetJK; 02-15-2013 at 05:40 AM.
#7
Super Moderator
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Posts: 11,043
Likes: 0
Received 83 Likes
on
75 Posts
Thanks guys. The notion of the carbon deposits glowing hot helps.
So is this indicative of piston rings not sealing well, or some other fundamental engine problem? Would / could synthetic oil or a different weight of oil help?
I did look a bit at the head issue, but was under the impression that that was a ticking that you would hear at idle, and I haven't really noticed this. My noise is more like a rattle coming from somewhere when in the aforementioned RPM range and under load (even moderate load). Truth is, I originally thought it might be coming from the transmission, but I took it to the dealer and they drove around with me in it and said it is spark knock, and that I needed to use the premium fuel. And then it did seem to improve, even go away temporarily when I started with the premium, so that seems to be the right track. But it has by no means vanished altogether.
I'm really hoping I can find a way to solve this so I can start 'investing' in my future happiness with mods, tires, etc.
So is this indicative of piston rings not sealing well, or some other fundamental engine problem? Would / could synthetic oil or a different weight of oil help?
I did look a bit at the head issue, but was under the impression that that was a ticking that you would hear at idle, and I haven't really noticed this. My noise is more like a rattle coming from somewhere when in the aforementioned RPM range and under load (even moderate load). Truth is, I originally thought it might be coming from the transmission, but I took it to the dealer and they drove around with me in it and said it is spark knock, and that I needed to use the premium fuel. And then it did seem to improve, even go away temporarily when I started with the premium, so that seems to be the right track. But it has by no means vanished altogether.
I'm really hoping I can find a way to solve this so I can start 'investing' in my future happiness with mods, tires, etc.
Trending Topics
#8
JK Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks guys,
I'll give it a try at some point soon (swamped with work at the moment). I will say that I don't actually notice any hesitation associated with the noise (like I used to when my old landcruiser was pinging). I did crawl underneath and look for any loose heat shields and everything seemed tight. It was warm on Saturday, and I noticed it seems a bit worse.
I'll report back on the results, may also visit the dealer.
(I did take a couple hour off on Saturday to pull the trigger on some BFG 33" ATs, so this JK and I are in for the long haul. Goodyear SRAs for sale 13k miles, 9/16 tread, if anyone is interested. )
I'll give it a try at some point soon (swamped with work at the moment). I will say that I don't actually notice any hesitation associated with the noise (like I used to when my old landcruiser was pinging). I did crawl underneath and look for any loose heat shields and everything seemed tight. It was warm on Saturday, and I noticed it seems a bit worse.
I'll report back on the results, may also visit the dealer.
(I did take a couple hour off on Saturday to pull the trigger on some BFG 33" ATs, so this JK and I are in for the long haul. Goodyear SRAs for sale 13k miles, 9/16 tread, if anyone is interested. )
#9
I'm taking my 2012 that has 18k on it to the dealer soon to start an oil consumption test it has grey smoke on start up and on acceleration sometimes and it doesn't quit per like it should. They had bad milling issues in the heads from what I heard and down here in the south a lot of overheating issues good luck.
#10
JK Newbie
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Longmeadow, MA
Posts: 22
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is the Cylinder Head issue the early 2012's have been having. It is common with all of the early 3.6 penastars. They have to replace the drivers side cylinder head. It usually is mis firing on cylinder 4. Do some searching on the forum. It is such a problem that the delerships are only allocated one cylinder head per month. It took my dealership 3 months to get one in for mine. Mine was actually mis firing on both the left and right banks, and yes the warmer the engine gets the louder it gets. Your dealership should know what the issue is. If they say they don't they are playing dumb, or theyr mechanics just hate doing the cylinder head job. The dealerships get 70 hrs. of labor from chrysler for the job. It took them about three days to complete mine and it runs great. Power has returned and not having any issues.
Check out these threads,
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...t=3.6+penastar
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...astar+problems
Check out these threads,
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...t=3.6+penastar
https://www.jk-forum.com/forums/stoc...astar+problems
Last edited by drich153; 02-21-2013 at 08:51 AM.