Who's breaking axle shafts??
#11
The D30 is not a weak axle. Numerous people run 35's with lockers in places like Johnson Valley without any trouble. I was one of them when I had my TJ. The HP30 on the JK is even better than the LP of the TJ. Mos t axle breakages on the 30 are driver error.
#12
Sponsoring Vendor
I broke my dana 30 front axle shaft after about 16000 miles running 37s since mile 10.
I think it held up pretty well. Alot of it was the open diff in the front.
We have replaced 4 sets of front rubicon axle shafts all the short side.
2 were running 35s and 2 running 37s. I think alot of this is caused by the locker .
Chromolly axle shafts will cure alot of this. Superior is working on the front axle shafts.
We have been testing the rear Superior chromoly Axle Shafts since March and added a Detroit Locker for the last 3 months.
REAR SUPERIOR 4340 HD CHROMOLY AXLE SHAFT KITS ARE NOW AVAILABLE AT OFF ROAD EVOLUTION>Starting Monday we will be taking phone orders for the kits and they should be available on line at www.offroadevolution.com sometime next week. They will be priced at $299.99 for the kit which includes bearings and seals.THESE AXLES ARE MADE IN THE USA
Puddlz you are number one on the list. Give us a call on Monday. Thanks for the order.
I think it held up pretty well. Alot of it was the open diff in the front.
We have replaced 4 sets of front rubicon axle shafts all the short side.
2 were running 35s and 2 running 37s. I think alot of this is caused by the locker .
Chromolly axle shafts will cure alot of this. Superior is working on the front axle shafts.
We have been testing the rear Superior chromoly Axle Shafts since March and added a Detroit Locker for the last 3 months.
REAR SUPERIOR 4340 HD CHROMOLY AXLE SHAFT KITS ARE NOW AVAILABLE AT OFF ROAD EVOLUTION>Starting Monday we will be taking phone orders for the kits and they should be available on line at www.offroadevolution.com sometime next week. They will be priced at $299.99 for the kit which includes bearings and seals.THESE AXLES ARE MADE IN THE USA
Puddlz you are number one on the list. Give us a call on Monday. Thanks for the order.
Last edited by Evolution; 08-10-2007 at 06:57 PM.
#15
I ran a D30 in my YJ starting out with 35's and a lock right and that damned thing broke if I looked at it wrong. However, a friend of mine has been wheeling his D30 front for years with an OX locker and alloy shafts on 36" IROKS and wheeling every bit as hard as those of us with one tons and 40's+ and never broken one. You never know for sure. It's right on the edge of strong enough vs not strong enough. Through in the variables of axles shafts, tire size, conditions (rocks, mud, bound up tight, etc) and driving style and that makes for the wide variance of opinions on good vs bad.
Personally, they break more than I'd like to think about which is one of the main reasons I went with a rubicon. Tires, rock sliders, the fancy sticker, hell even the transfer case can be replaced easliy or added to an X model, etc. But add all this with the front D44 and it's worth it to me.
I'd like to run 37's but for now I think I'll stick with 35's for some insurance. I'll wait for the 37's when I can add alloy shafts and new drive shafts.
Personally, they break more than I'd like to think about which is one of the main reasons I went with a rubicon. Tires, rock sliders, the fancy sticker, hell even the transfer case can be replaced easliy or added to an X model, etc. But add all this with the front D44 and it's worth it to me.
I'd like to run 37's but for now I think I'll stick with 35's for some insurance. I'll wait for the 37's when I can add alloy shafts and new drive shafts.
#16
JK Newbie
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Kansas City, KS
Posts: 66
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have broke 2, that's right, 2 Dana 44 rear axle shafts and don't know what I keep doing wrong. I have 35's and must be binding. Can someone please explain this? I've heard that binding before you have to bump over an obstacle is the cause. Any help would be greatly appreciated as this is getting expensive! It's always the rear driver side as well.
Thanks!!!
Brian
Thanks!!!
Brian
#17
So far, so good. I try to lay off the skinny pedal but have run the hard lines at Holy Cross (not Cleveland Rock) in the rain. The lockers work perfectly, so I also try to keep the front open unless I really need it. Before the lift and tires we did a snow run involving tons of high revs and 2-3 feet of snow. There was some activation of the brake-lock differential so I mashed the ESP button for 10 secs to turn it all off just to be safe. The odometer says "ESP OFF" and it behaves normally then. I'm betting some of the failures are happening when a wheel gets loose, accelerates rapidly, then gets slammed to a stop by the brake. Anyway, no problems of any kind so far. Pritchett in October should really test it...
#18
JK Enthusiast
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Central FLORIDA
Posts: 174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I this what you are looking for?
I shreaded the front passenger side axle shaft at the U-Joint, Like a hand grenade went off in there. Found only small bits of the u-joint.
I was wheelin a hard uphill technical climb, a little off camber, and bang!
fixed it myself and will upgrade to co-mo's next time they break.
So this happened at just over 16,000 miles, and I am only running 33x12.5's
I was wheelin a hard uphill technical climb, a little off camber, and bang!
fixed it myself and will upgrade to co-mo's next time they break.
So this happened at just over 16,000 miles, and I am only running 33x12.5's
#20
JK Freak
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 739
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have broke 2, that's right, 2 Dana 44 rear axle shafts and don't know what I keep doing wrong. I have 35's and must be binding. Can someone please explain this? I've heard that binding before you have to bump over an obstacle is the cause. Any help would be greatly appreciated as this is getting expensive! It's always the rear driver side as well.
Thanks!!!
Brian
Thanks!!!
Brian